City of Wolves by
Willow Palecek
My rating:
2 of 5 stars
***I received an ARC from Netgalley in return for a fair and honest review***
Alexander Drake is a down on his luck private detective. Drunk and in need of a job, he is hired/forced into accepting a nobleman’s proposition to find the murderer of his father. Although Drake has sworn off working for the nobility (too much trouble despite the money), he’s accepts an offer he really couldn’t refuse anyway. And so we begin on a fast paced journey through the fictional city of Lupenwald--complete with werewolves, shady detectives, and mafia like religious figures.
City of Wolves ticks off all of the typical mystery boxes--private detective down on his luck, wealthy client with family secrets, police angry over amateur interference, and even a Poirot like scene in which everyone gathers in the drawing room and the mystery is solved. However, despite having the pieces to a good mystery romp (I mean who doesn’t like a good gaslamp noir werewolf mystery), the puzzle never quite came together for me. I found the story confusing and shallow.
I understand with only 100 or so pages to play with, there is not enough time to write an epic. The pacing was too quick, too overcrowded. Okay, we’re at a manor house. Oh wait, now we’re doing an autopsy with some detective who seems like he has some connection to Drake in the past, but not really sure. There’s some sort of allusion to a war in the past. Oh and now we’re off again to the city to see a war veteran. Oh wait, some vicar, who is apparently a mob boss shows up. Is Drake working for him now? Is he some sort of future character. Huh? I think the author was trying to show a need for urgency on Drake’s part, but all of his movement back and forth seemed forced and not as dramatic as I believe the author intended. The solution to the mystery was anti-climatic. The big reveal didn’t really feel all that important or big by the end.
City of Wolves has good bones. There are the bones of an interesting world and interesting characters if they are given the chance and page space to come through and truly join the narrative. Drake seems like he will be snarky, hardboiled investigator perfect for gaslamp noir. At the moment, I don’t see myself actively seeking out a second installment, but perhaps that will change with time. ⅖ stars.
View all my reviews